i think the least ignored issue with gen 1 (outside of serious fans of the series) is how godawful the movepools are on so many pokemon. nearly every pokemon that isn't a normal type has such a shallow movepool (and even some normal types do) that it makes teambuilding a bit of a chore no matter what
I agree with you and like theyre on another level this gen but even up to gen 3 some movesets suck, ofc there was also the infamous meme of how long it took for flareon to get flare blitz ?_?
And at some later point, gen 6 maybe I feel we had the opposite problem and some movesets became too broad. There are some really stupid move cuts now and I don’t wanna excuse that but I can get why they had the idea to remove some moves from some mons
Not a direct response to what you said, but I do feel like a lot of people want Pokémon games to be challenging, but also have the freedom to use a large variety of Pokémon with a large variety of powerful moves. I think what a lot of people don't put together is that part of the challenge comes from the limited movepools, having to sacrifice slots for HMs, etc.
But I get it, when I found out my Vileplume's strongest STAB option was fucking Mega Drain, I was disappointed
People can hit this with the "objectively bad" argument all they want but Sun & Moon will never have a professor who can't remember his own grandson's name
It's sad that we never have had another puzzle box region design like Kanto, at least not to the same extent. Giving a fresh water to the gate officer to access Saffron was actually such a satisfying "puzzle." Even just on a dialogue level, the sheer absurdity of it was just so charming.
It's sad that the oversaturation of Gen 1 elements in the modern games (not to mention the era of insufferable genwunners) have soured so many people on Gen 1, to the point where people won't even acknowledge that there are things that Red and Blue did quite well, positive qualities that have been lost in the newer titles. Yes, these games are massively flawed, but you go on Reddit and all you see is people bashing them or at the very least dismissing them entirely, and that's a real shame.
as a millenial who was in the core audience of the pokémon craze in the late 90s, it confuses me to no end that gen 1 is only 3.5 avg on here and actually one of the worst rated gen of all??? wth
But I get it, when I found out my Vileplume's strongest STAB option was fucking Mega Drain, I was disappointed
It's sad that the oversaturation of Gen 1 elements in the modern games (not to mention the era of insufferable genwunners) have soured so many people on Gen 1, to the point where people won't even acknowledge that there are things that Red and Blue did quite well, positive qualities that have been lost in the newer titles. Yes, these games are massively flawed, but you go on Reddit and all you see is people bashing them or at the very least dismissing them entirely, and that's a real shame.