Quake 4

I kinda wish you could rate the singleplayer and multiplayer separately because while the former is just a little bit wack the latter super holds up

After a kind of dreadful first hour or so, it picks up and becomes a halfway decent shooter. Still the worst Quake campaign, but not a total trash fire.

pretty dogshit

The Xbox 360 port is one of the biggest technical messes I've played, I'm not one to dog on Frames per second but this was flat-out unplayable at many parts.
Other than that when it worked it was okay, not remarkable but okay.

Pretty much a faster Doom 3. I still prefer Doom 3 though because the Hell levels are just the perfect interpretation of Hell I've seen in a game, and Quake 4 almost has this Halo element to it in terms of aesthetics, but with body horror. That body horror though is pretty nasty, especially with the lower-tech low poly models. The vehicle sections are pretty awful, but the core shooting can be fun with awesome sound design. I just wish one day, we get the dark fantasy version of Quake back in a future installment, rather the Strogg again.

wooow it's doom 3 except somehow even fucking worse

This is better than Quake II