http://www.fiveeightforums.com/
Just a warning; I may be a little easy on the ratings.

5 - Epic to the most extreme degree possible. Nothing wrong with it at all, and tons and tons of things right/amazing.

4.5 - Incredibly good. Nothing wrong with it, but it's still possible within the boundaries of the universe to be better.

4 - Basically flawless, but not very amazing.

3.5 - Good with some flaws.

3 - Okay.

2.5 - Kind of sucks. Not too much, though.

2 - Sucks to a higher degree.

1.5 - Terrible with no redeeming qualities.

1 - Worst you could possible be.

.5 - Except for this.