Concerning your review of Nihilist by Decapitated.. why listen to an album in a genre that you dislike and then rate it based on the fact that you dislike the genre?

Good question - because I don't rate albums between their relative peers, but because I either like them or don't like them. Read the critic though - in the genre, it's not bad. Like Britney Spears is not bad in the pop genre, but she won't touch Abba.
I guess I could give a 5 stars to a death metal album, but I haven't found it yet ;)