Where Heart Gold/Soul Silver towered, they stood on the foundation laid by Platinum.
I look at the game with rose-tinted glasses, absolutely; but every time I pick up the game, nothing is aged. With each passing try, I ask myself, "Are these rose-tinted glasses? Am I even wearing such glasses?" With every flaw of Diamond and Pearl, and every bore from the generations previous, Platinum fixes, expands, cements, and towers head and shoulders above all others. Like Gold/Silver/Crystal to Red/Blue/Yellow, Platinum holds this position for Diamond and Pearl, and arguably for the generation before.
Starting with the obvious, the Pokedex: with new Pokemon comes new requirement for remembrance. Will the new designs be too busy, reminiscent of the failed Digimon? Or will they be too nostalgic, stunting the progress of the series? Gen IV shows no sign of either, adding classic starters, hilarious HM-slaves, and enjoyable designs and variants, we see an expounded group of evolution lines. These weren't even necessary, though they feel welcomed and expected. Platinum allows you to catch the most of the trio of Gen IV; the last of its kind in this sense, and shows perfection in this endeavor, only missing a handful that most would not be too sad to realize are gone.
Continuing with this comes the trading mechanic; while Gen II set a sad precedence in not being able to trade Pokemon to the next generation, Platinum changes this with the Safari Area that allows Gen III to be pushed as Safari Zone Pokemon. This mechanic, novel then and since, is unrivaled and shows an appreciation for the demographic and fans. This love for the game, culture, and memories easily allows for those to continue to fill their Pokedex, slowly and masterfully filling the gaps left by those unattainable.
But what of this novel mechanism? Feeding into the impeccable world-building that Gamefreak was known for, the unique trading zone is only a piece of the wonderful world of Sinnoh, where the unrealized traits of the region in Diamond/Pearl are grown in minute, yet impactful ways; now, there are seasons, now there are movements in places unseen, now there is character pouring from every corner of each town, and the culture of the fictitious world is given to the player. With each gym leader comes a town with their character and seemingly and sense of exploration that only the gym leaders seem to understand, and when everything is finally said and done for each town, each gym leader fulfills your adventure with the classic battle and subsequent badge. With each passing town is growth not seen since Gen II, and arguably better.
This growth is probably the pinnacle of the game. Where Gen II introduced the phone for re-battling, Gen IV refines this with the Lodge; you can now battle Gym Leaders as they casually hang out in the cafe (bar?). The coziness of the area, where you can find your rival (Barry), twice a week, your newly purchased house, and the newly established Battle Frontier (the best aspect of Gen III), you will be hard pressed to be bored during the story, after, and beyond. To this day, the replayability is almost unique to this game, and is what every other Pokemon game strives for after.
The amalgamation of all of the best parts of the previous generations, coupled with the novelty of this one, and the melancholic, dark, and intense story line, this game is a coming of age for anyone looking to enjoy Pokemon, and even other RPGs.
Body
tips
Formatting [b]text[/b] - bold [i]text[/i] - italic [s]strikethrough[/s] - strikethrough [tt]text[/tt] - fixed-width type [color red]text[/color] - colored text (full list) [spoiler]text[/spoiler] - Text hidden with spoiler cover [https://www.example.com/page/,Link to another site] - Link to another site
Linking When you mention an album, artist, film, game, label, etc - it's recommended to link to the item the first time you mention it. Doing so will make it easier to search for your post and give it more visibility. To link an item, use the search box above, or find the shortcut that appears on the page that you want to link. You can customize the link name of shortcuts by using the format [Artist12345,Custom Name].
Formatting [b]text[/b] - bold [i]text[/i] - italic [s]strikethrough[/s] - strikethrough [tt]text[/tt] - fixed-width type [color red]text[/color] - colored text (full list) [spoiler]text[/spoiler] - Text hidden with spoiler cover [https://www.example.com/page/,Link to another site] - Link to another site
Linking When you mention an album, artist, film, game, label, etc - it's recommended to link to the item the first time you mention it. Doing so will make it easier to search for your post and give it more visibility. To link an item, use the search box above, or find the shortcut that appears on the page that you want to link. You can customize the link name of shortcuts by using the format [Artist12345,Custom Name].
I wish I didn't think I was too cool for Pokemon in the ds era. It is a little slow and I don't find the artwork to be as charming as the old games but other than that this is very good. Cant wait to try the other ds games.
imo, overrated as fuck. for as much as this fixed in d/p, it didn't fix the sinnoh being one of the worst regions to traverse in the whole series, the gen 4 pokemon designs are probably some of the weakest barring a select few, and having the ABSOLUTE worst HM uses in the entire series (which is already terrible in on itself), and the game is still laughably slow. i personally believe gen 4 would be one of the weakest gens if it didn't have the physical/special split and HG/SS in it. i can play gen 2, 3, 5, and even 7 over and over again but despite what platinum does to fix d/p, i find myself quitting after only 2 gyms every time i try to give it another try. it's a massive shame because i have probably the most nostalgia and time played with gen 4 as a kid, specifically d/p/pt, but as i get older i find myself disliking it more and more...
What is so bad about the traversal? You can get around the entire map in like 5 minutes.
Hard disagree on the mon designs, I think most of the gen 4 mons are peak. Just look at lucario, togekiss, luxray, staraptor, garchomp, all of the starters, weavil, etc… all sick as fuck and my favorites of the whole series. Giratina-O? Come on
I agree the HMs are annoying as hell but at least you get bibarel
I guess the game is slow but all of them are from this era
Biggest criticism I can level at this game is that it’s too easy but it also has one of the harder E4s
I’ve replayed this far more than any other Pokémon game
going around the routes and caves always just feel more like a chore than fun to me - really hate exploring them. there are a lot of good pokemon designs, i love all you listed plus dusknoir, but a lot just feel so bland to me.
hm problem is more because you have to have your dedicated HM user PLUS using HMs on main party mons i may not wanna use them on. mount coronet is horrific, you need so many TMs for a MANDITORY dungeon. i love gen 3 and it can have frustrating HM issues too, but luckily you get to a point where you can just box a mon. plus gen 3 HMs are much better than a lot of gen 4 HMs in terms of being good and viable in battles (i've never really had issues with surf and strength, for example)
yea the slowness effects the whole gen horrible and it's frustrating. i love hg/ss but it does effect those games too
easiness thing doesn't bug me too much, i think personally this game has one of the easier E4's outside of cynthia having a competitively viable team lol
idk, i just can't fully get into d/p/pt. i really really wanna retry platinum at some point but again, i end up putting it down too fast because i just lose interest. maybe on a proper replay, i'll feel different, but it's just hard to push myself to keep playing
people act like this fixed everything wrong with diamond and pearl when this still has a lot of the same issues, albeit on a marginally smaller scale. like the gameplay loop and exploration still feels like a chore and it still runs like piss. if it wasnt for the aesthetics and nostalgia of this game people would not view it as highly as they do lol
Hard disagree on the mon designs, I think most of the gen 4 mons are peak. Just look at lucario, togekiss, luxray, staraptor, garchomp, all of the starters, weavil, etc… all sick as fuck and my favorites of the whole series. Giratina-O? Come on
I agree the HMs are annoying as hell but at least you get bibarel
I guess the game is slow but all of them are from this era
Biggest criticism I can level at this game is that it’s too easy but it also has one of the harder E4s
I’ve replayed this far more than any other Pokémon game
hm problem is more because you have to have your dedicated HM user PLUS using HMs on main party mons i may not wanna use them on. mount coronet is horrific, you need so many TMs for a MANDITORY dungeon. i love gen 3 and it can have frustrating HM issues too, but luckily you get to a point where you can just box a mon. plus gen 3 HMs are much better than a lot of gen 4 HMs in terms of being good and viable in battles (i've never really had issues with surf and strength, for example)
yea the slowness effects the whole gen horrible and it's frustrating. i love hg/ss but it does effect those games too
easiness thing doesn't bug me too much, i think personally this game has one of the easier E4's outside of cynthia having a competitively viable team lol
idk, i just can't fully get into d/p/pt. i really really wanna retry platinum at some point but again, i end up putting it down too fast because i just lose interest. maybe on a proper replay, i'll feel different, but it's just hard to push myself to keep playing