Here's how my main team is built: Captain: Peach First Base: Daisy Second Base: Birdo Short Stop: Red Kritter Third Base: King K Rool Outfielders: Mario, Luigi, and Yoshi Relief Pitcher: Petey Piranha (or Wiggler)
Superstar Baseball has much better controls and gameplay. Shaking the Wii remote like a madman to do literally everything is not very good game design - I mean, maybe for children.
Captain: Peach
First Base: Daisy
Second Base: Birdo
Short Stop: Red Kritter
Third Base: King K Rool
Outfielders: Mario, Luigi, and Yoshi
Relief Pitcher: Petey Piranha (or Wiggler)